20230412 - Village Council Regular Public Meeting Minutes
A REGULAR PUBLIC MEETING OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD HELD IN THE SYDNEY V. STOLDT, JR. COURT ROOM OF THE RIDGEWOOD VILLAGE HALL, 131 NORTH MAPLE AVENUE, RIDGEWOOD, NEW JERSEY, ON APRIL 12, 2023 AT 7:30 P.M.
1. CALL TO ORDER – OPEN PUBLIC MEETINGS ACT – ROLL CALL – FLAG SALUTE
Mayor Vagianos called the meeting to order at 7:37 P.M. and read the Statement of Compliance with the Open Public Meetings Act. At roll call the following were present: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos. Also present was Heather Mailander, Village Manager/Village Clerk, and Matthew Rogers, Village Attorney.
Mayor Vagianos led those in attendance in the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag.
2. ACCEPTANCE OF FINANCIAL REPORTS AND APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Bills, Claims, and Vouchers, and Statement of Funds on Hand as of January 31, 2023 and March 31, 2023, be accepted as submitted. Deputy Mayor Perron seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: Councilmember Reynolds
Councilmember Reynolds abstained, because she had not had time to review the bill list.
3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Council minutes of January 25, February 22, and March 22, 2023, having been reviewed by the Village Council and now available in the Village Clerk’s Office, be approved as submitted. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
4. PROCLAMATIONS
A. PROCLAIM APRIL AS TREE PLANTING MONTH AND APRIL 28, 2023 AS ARBOR DAY
Councilmember Winograd read the following proclamation:
B. PROCLAIM MAY 7-13, 2023 NATIONAL DRINKING WATER WEEK
Councilmember Weitz read the following proclamation:
C. PROCLAIM MAY AS BUILDING SAFETY MONTH
Councilmember Reynolds read the following proclamation:
D. PROCLAIM MAY AS OLDER AMERICANS MONTH
Mayor Vagianos read the following proclamation:
E. RECOGNIZE NO MOW MAY IN RIDGEWOOD
Deputy Mayor Perron read the following proclamation. Mayor Vagianos thanked Frank Mortimer who was the driving force behind this latter Proclamation, and he encouraged everyone to join in this worthy effort.
5. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Before public comments began, Councilmember Reynolds asked Mayor Vagianos to please extend the public comments portion this evening, since there is a very important vote that will take place regarding the Schedler property and there were many people waiting to speak, both in attendance at the meeting and at home. However, Mayor Vagianos indicated that, as usual, a limit of ten speakers in person and four calling in from home, will be able to speak at the beginning of the meeting. He said that if the time for public comments were extended at this meeting, they would have to extend it at every meeting.
Tony Damiano, 274 South Broad Street, stated that he is Executive Director of the Ridgewood Guild. He thanked everyone for letting him cut in line so that he could speak, since he is supposed to be attending a film festival meeting. Mr. Damiano said that he wanted to report on the number of vacancies in the Central Business District (CBD). Two years ago, there were 43 vacancies, and he was pleased to report that there are currently only 13 vacancies in the CBD. He said that he can never remember such a low number of vacancies. These vacancies include Wachovia Bank and Capital One Bank, which have been sitting vacant for over a decade, as well as Blue Foundry Bank, Hillman Electric (which will probably be subdivided), Ann Taylor, Gattinolli, and Chico’s. Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt is the only business he knows of that has closed this year in Ridgewood.
Mr. Damiano indicated that The Villa and Apricot Lane Boutique will be relocating to the La Casita space, and Woofgang Bakery has moved to Glen Rock. Lora Celli Salon and Vera’s Bridal Shop are vacant on the west side of the Village. New tenants coming soon include a gelato shop taking over the space formerly tenanted by Samba Bowls, Dairy Queen will take over the space formerly occupied by Little Nest Portraits, a restaurant will take over the space formerly occupied by Exclusive Day Spa, a Persian restaurant will take over the space formerly occupied by Finca, and the old Gap/Joseph E. Banks space will be occupied by a new tenant as well.
Mr. Damiano stated that, in the last two weeks, three new businesses have opened in the Village: Paris Baguette, which took over the space formerly occupied by Amano; Surreal Creamery took over the space formerly occupied by the Originals; and Eyes of Ridgewood took over the space formerly occupied by Papyrus. He encouraged all residents to support local businesses.
Richard Brooks, 777 East Ridgewood Avenue, said that he wanted to read a letter from the Parks, Recreation and Conservation Board, on which he serves as Chair: “Dear Mayor and Council: The PRC Board is passionately dedicated to our Village’s recreational facilities and municipal parks, acting as stewards to ensure the maximum number of residents have the opportunity to utilize our beautiful open space and parks and thoroughly enjoy the outdoors in active and passive recreational pursuits. At the PRC Board’s March 28, 2023 meeting, we discussed the Schedler property and, based upon the mission of the PRC Board, we would like to provide the Village Council with the Parks, Recreation and Conservation Board’s recommendations for how to develop the Schedler property, so that it serves the greatest number of Village residents. First, just as HealthBarn has done so much good for our community and is the cornerstone of the Irene Habernickel Family Park, the PRC Board recommends finding a tenant for the Schedler house that will serve our community, honor its history, and attract visitors to the Schedler property. Second, the Board fully supports having public restroom facilities on the property, which will benefit the greatest number of visitors, especially families with young children, and will allow many of those who go to the park, to thoroughly enjoy their time on the property, without having to rush off hastily or cut their visit short.
“Third, the PRC Board strongly supports having a playground or play structure for young children to enjoy, as it will bring families to the property and provide our youngest residents with an area where they can benefit from unstructured free play, while engaging in physical activity. Fourth, incorporating a walking path into the plans is a must-have, as it will encourage the passive use of the park and, similar to the Habernickel Park, the PRC Board foresees a significant number of residents using and benefiting from walking or strolling on the property. This amenity encourages socialization and a greater sense of community. Fifth, since we also promote the benefits of wildscapes, green space, and natural habitats for pollinators and wildlife, we strongly recommend that the greatest number of trees either be saved or replaced, and that native pollinator-friendly vegetation be planted throughout the property, providing a green space that can be enjoyed by visitors to the property and utilized by the non-human species that call the property home.
“Finally, it is the Parks, Recreation and Conservation Board’s recommendation for the Village Council to incorporate a full-sized, multipurpose turf field into its plans for the property. This will ensure that the greatest number of residents are able to use the field. It is our experience that having an undersized field will severely limit its use, while a full-sized, multipurpose field will be used by many age groups and serve the greatest diversity of athletes in the various sports that they play. Open use is encouraged, as well as group use, requiring a larger space. The PRC Board coordinates our community recreation programs and, in doing so, works with the Village’s Field Committee comprised of the various sports leagues in Ridgewood Public Schools. We are acutely aware of the stress our current fields are suffering and will recognize the numerous benefits that a full-sized, multipurpose turf field at Schedler will bring to our community. Village Councilmembers, we, the members of the PRC Board, meet each month for the sole purpose of bringing what is best for all of our Village’s parks and recreational spaces. Our recommendations are based upon the PRC Board’s primary knowledge of Ridgewood’s active and passive recreational needs and how the Schedler property can best meet these needs and serve the greatest number of residents now, and into the future.”
Ellie Gruber, 229 South Irving Street, stated that she was speaking this evening as President of the Friends of the Historic Zabriskie-Schedler House, and on behalf of Manish Shrimali, Vice President of that organization. Ms. Gruber said that, upon the advice of their attorney, the Friends of the Historic Zabriskie-Schedler House are formally objecting to the plan by the majority of the Village Council to construct a full-sized 90-foot baseball and football field, thus voiding the agreed upon 2018 plan and resolution for a medium-sized soccer field. Ms. Gruber said that this new plan will encroach upon the house, which has been designated as historic by the County, State and Federal governments.
Ms. Gruber continued by saying that the proposed plan is out of character with the historic designation of the house and is inconsistent with grants and designations. The Friends of the Historic Zabriskie-Schedler House are requesting that their $40,000.00 donation to the Village for the house be returned. When these funds were originally donated, it was with the understanding that the 2018 plans would be carried out, which provided a large space between the house and the field.
Ms. Gruber said that the decision of the Village Council to hire a consultant for the purpose of removing the historic designation from the house and property will result in public hearings before the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO), which will cause delays and result in additional expenditures of taxpayer money. She stated that the Village Council allocating the sum of $500,000.00 in the 2023 budget, to be used for construction of a new field at the Schedler property, at a time when services to residents are being cut, is inappropriate.
Ms. Gruber said that if the Village Council votes this evening to construct a larger field on the Schedler property and attempts to remove the historical designation from the house and property, such decisions will result in further delays for years, before the property is developed. However, by reverting back to the original agreed upon plan, construction could begin almost immediately. Ms. Gruber indicated that a two-year delay was incurred when the Village Engineer submitted unauthorized plans to SHPO, which were ultimately rejected. She urged the Village Council to go back to the original plans for this property. Ms. Gruber indicated that Mr. Shrimali stated that the Village Council’s actions regarding the Schedler project are contradictory to the promise made to complete this project as early as possible. Instead, the Village Council has proposed vast changes to the original plans, which were developed over the past ten years.
Ms. Gruber concluded by stating that the revised proposed plan is not reflective of the historic nature of the house and the nearby surroundings. She said that a larger field will cause additional traffic in the area and significant safety concerns for the neighborhood children. Ms. Gruber stated that they are, therefore, raising a formal objection to the new plan and urge the Village Council to complete the implementation of the agreed upon 2018 plans. She said that a majority of Village residents are united in opposition to the actions of the Village Council and are willing to take all steps necessary to ensure the acceptable execution of the previously agreed upon plan.
Mayor Vagianos respectfully asked that decorum in the room be maintained during public comments, including shouting from the audience.
Scott Muller, 118 John Street, said that he has lived in Ridgewood for 28 years. He said that he wanted to shed some light on the concern that the health of children will be placed at risk if they play on a medium-sized, multipurpose field at Schedler Park. A concern has also been raised that particulates and pollution from Route 17 will cause asthma and affect the respiratory systems of children. Mr. Muller said that Ridgewood is not like Los Angeles, with bumper-to-bumper traffic and long-idling car engines. He said that a child may play on the field at the Schedler property once or twice a season, due to rotation of the fields. Mr. Muller said that he was confident that the children in the Schedler neighborhood have played in their backyards for years, right next to Route 17. He stated that there was no difference between the children playing in their backyards and playing on a field at the Schedler property.
Mr. Muller said that natural grass is safer and cheaper. However, he stated that natural grass needs fertilizer, pesticides, irrigation, seeding and constant mowing. He wondered if everyone knew that these agricultural chemicals also seep into the ground. Mr. Muller said that the Village has spent a lot of money on grass field maintenance throughout the years. He mentioned that the Ridgewood Baseball and Softball Association (RBSA) has already spent $35,000.00 in the past year for the upkeep of grass fields in the Village.
Regarding the component of PFAS in artificial turf, Mr. Muller stated that artificial turf has been around since 1964. He said that the Federal government would have banned artificial turf by now, after 57 years, if it were discovered that it caused cancer or defects in children. He stated that when Veterans Field floods, fecal matter and road runoff, such as oil, gasoline, mud, silt, trash and yard debris, coat the fields. After remediation, a fine dust remains and becomes airborne as children play on the field. However, when a turf field floods and dries, any dirt and debris is vacuumed up, leaving no such dust.
Regarding parking and volume of cars near the Schedler property, Mr. Muller cautioned the neighbors by stating that, with a small field rather than a large one, only younger children will play on the field. Many parents, grandparents and other relatives will converge upon the property (minimum of three cars per player) to see the younger children play, which will cause traffic problems. With a minimum of 15 to 20 players per team, that will amount to between 100 and 150 cars coming to the Schedler property at a time, during a game. He said that no one carpools with young children, since it is too “new and fun” for the families to watch them play. However, a larger field will attract older players who do carpool, and some teams use a bus or a van to get to the field, and there are less parents watching the game.
Mr. Muller stated that there are over 150 baseball and softball teams in Ridgewood, both recreational and travel programs. He said facilities outside of the Village are charging teams to hold practices because there is a lack of field availability in the Village. He said that the Schedler property should be able to be used by as many taxpayers as possible. Mr. Muller said that the park should be named “Memorial Park” or “Remembrance Park” in honor of Ridgewood residents who perished on 9/11.
Mayor Vagianos again reminded those in attendance at the meeting that they should remain quiet and be respectful while other people are speaking at the podium.
Lauren Bond, 335 Kensington Drive, tearfully stated that she and her family are very upset by the comments made to her and her family by people who are opposed to the larger field being constructed at the Schedler property. Her twin sister left the room in tears after these remarks. She pointed out that the young athletes in Ridgewood represent the future of the Village, and she is very upset that there are people trying to take away the field on which they can play their chosen sports. Lauren stated that she is a sophomore at Ridgewood High School, plays three sports, and is a high honor student. She is speaking this evening because she has personally experienced the fact that there are not enough fields in Ridgewood to accommodate all of the youth athletes. She has also witnessed the messy condition of the fields after a storm.
Lauren stated that she has just returned from her softball game, which was played on the multipurpose turf field at Immaculate Heart Academy (IHA). She loved playing on that field, and stated that while she played her softball game, there were lacrosse players practicing concurrently at the other end of the same field. Lauren said that she thought it was great that multiple sports could be played on the same field. She urged the Village Councilmembers to vote in favor of the multipurpose field at the Schedler property and give the young athletes in Ridgewood the chance to play the sports they love.
Lauren Cuneo, 373 Mountain Avenue, stated that she has spoken twice before the Village Council as a representative and current board member of the Maroons Soccer Club, and as the mother of three Ridgewood athletes. Ms. Cuneo said that she supported the construction of a large multiuse turf field on the Schedler property. She said that there is a very clear field shortage in Ridgewood, and more space is needed for Village youth and adults to play freely, as well as in an organized fashion. More importantly, dry land is needed in Ridgewood that can be utilized by everyone. She said that a small field will not maximize use across many sports, but instead will be limited to only soccer games played by children aged 12 years and younger.
Ms. Cuneo stated that the field near Hawes School is an excellent example of a multiuse sports field, built with turf in a neighborhood with limited parking. There is a large soccer field with a lacrosse field overlay, football field overlay, and a baseball diamond overlay. In addition, there are two small-sided soccer field overlays. She said that it is obvious that a large field is the optimal field to construct for everyone in Ridgewood to use.
Regarding artificial turf, Ms. Cuneo said that it was her understanding that the original plans called for the use of turf. She urged the Village Council to vote in favor of a large turf field for everyone to utilize.
Ms. Cuneo said that she wanted to read a letter from Chuck Handy: “I apologize I cannot be there to speak. I’m at my daughter’s first Ridgewood High School flag football game. I live at 695 Kingsbridge Lane and I am in support of a large-sized turf field. I was the Maroons Soccer Club President for five years, and I’ve coached within the RBSA organization for ten years. I very much understand the need for a full-sided field and baseball diamond. I live less than a block away from the site and understand the implications it brings, but know in my heart that the kids need more fields, as it is near impossible for administrators to schedule games. Thank you for your consideration and, please note, my opinion is mine and not of my wife, Mary Lou Handy. Best regards, Chuck.”
Bill Bond, 335 Kensington Drive, said that he has lived in Ridgewood for 18 years. His daughter Lauren, who spoke previously, was crying because her twin sister had left the meeting this evening in tears after someone waiting in line to speak against the large field at the Schedler property referred to his wife as a “bad mother” and to both daughters as “rude.” Mr. Bond thanked the Village Council, Village Engineer, and everyone else involved with the development of the Schedler property. He said that he wanted to correct a previous speaker who indicated that there will be a 90-foot baseball diamond constructed on the property. Mr. Bond said that Ridgewood is probably the only town in New Jersey that has only one 60-foot x 90-foot baseball diamond, which is located at Veterans Field.
Mr. Bond said that weather patterns have caused serious flooding on the Village’s fields. He said that there is no solution that will make everybody happy. He urged the Village Councilmembers who plan to vote against the large turf field at the Schedler property to reconsider their position. He stated that their legacy should not be one in which they stood up for a minority of people from one generation who do not want this field in their backyard. However, he stated that future generations will be fighting for the opportunity to play sports, and approving the construction of a large turf field, would be a fine legacy to leave behind. He said that the arguments against turf are invalid, since there are already three existing turf fields in the Village, which exist without opposition. He urged all Village Councilmembers to vote for the large turf field.
Roger Williams, Maiden Head (Lawrence Township), New Jersey, congratulated the young woman (Lauren Bond) who spoke earlier this evening. He said that no one in the room wanted to deny youth the opportunity to play the sports that they love. At the April 3, 2023 meeting, Councilmember Weitz stated, “On the history piece, candidly, I have not found this one particular persuasive.” Mr. Williams stated that despite having a “fully realized” report from Hunter Research, a highly respected archaeological research firm endorsed by the Chair of New Jersey’s Crossroads of the American Revolution, along with other respected historical organizations, Councilmember Weitz feels that he is better qualified to determine the history of the Schedler property, which is listed on the New Jersey and National Registries of Historic Places.
Mr. Marshall said that he appreciated the fact that Village residents need sports fields, but he questioned why they need the field at the Schedler property in particular. He said that before the property is torn up, the Village Councilmembers should abide by the recommendations of a reputable firm such as Hunter Research, which is respected by New Jersey’s historic community. Mr. Marshall said that Councilmember Weitz also stated, “there is no win-win.” However, Mr. Marshall does feel that there is a win-win opportunity. He said that the people on the dais are appealing to sports constituents, but most of the neighbors near the Schedler property said that the win-win would be accomplished by following the original plans for the property. These plans would provide a wonderful park for families, while respecting the historical significance of the ground, or in the words of Ms. Milian, “practical preservation.”
Mr. Marshall said that by respecting the property, the Village Council could offer a place for all families throughout the region to enjoy, including educating visitors about the history, which took place on the property and Ridgewood’s role in the founding of our nation. Those visitors from outside of Ridgewood would then visit the CBD and shop and dine, supporting the community as a whole.
Mr. Marshall stated that Councilmember Weitz’s “homework” is incomplete. Mr. Marshall is the State Historian for the New Jersey Society of the Sons of the American Revolution, President of the Princeton Chapter of the Sons of the American Revolution, a former board member of the Princeton Battlefield Preservation Society, and advisor to the American Battlefield Trust – Save Princeton Battlefield Project.
At the last meeting, Mr. Marshall said that Mr. Primavera stated that he worked on the Princeton Battlefield seven times since the early 1980s. Mr. Primavera explained that, “We did massive historical research and massive amounts of archaeological research.” Mr. Marshall said that he could not stop laughing when Mr. Primavera stated that, “Up to that point, no one had really reconstructed the Battle of Princeton.” Mr. Primavera then claimed, “Princeton hired us on a number of occasions and I’ve been involved for over 30 years.” Mr. Marshall said that he has been involved with the Princeton Battlefield for over 50 years and, aside from Mr. Primavera’s rather notorious reputation in New Jersey’s history community, the only time he has heard Mr. Primavera’s name mentioned was when Mr. Primavera contacted the attorney for the Princeton Battlefield Project and offered to write a letter about work that had already been done by them. Mr. Marshall urged the Village Councilmembers to do their homework and vet Mr. Primavera.
Kristina Milian, 530 West Saddle River Road, stated that she was in support of a small grass field at the Schedler property and that she objects to the construction of a large turf field. Ms. Milian stated that the Green Amendment is on the agenda this evening and she wanted to read a letter from the Delaware Riverkeeper Network, which oversees that amendment and states that the Village Council is unqualified to vote on the amendment.
Ms. Milian read: “Dear Mayor Paul, The Delaware Riverkeeper Network is writing to express our concerns regarding the recent decision of the Village of Ridgewood to sign the Green Amendment, while also planning to remove acres of trees at the historic Schedler property for a turf sports field. This decision is in direct opposition to the principles outlined in the amendment and we urge you to reconsider. As you know, it is the Delaware Riverkeeper Network, under the leadership of Maya Van Rosen, that literally wrote the book about the need to adopt the Green Amendment. It is critical that governments at all levels support this initiative in its entirety, not selectively. The forest clearing and installation of artificial turf has known and measurable negative impacts on groundwater, localized flooding, air quality, habitat destruction, and fragmentation. The potential risks to the health and well-being of the community and environment cannot be ignored. We implore you to prioritize the safety and health of the community and explore alternative options that are more environmentally friendly and sustainable. We find it hypocritical that the Village Council would sign the Green Amendment, which declares that clean air and water and a healthy environment are every Ridgewood resident’s inalienable right, while simultaneously planning to undertake such substantially damaging environmental action. We hope that you will consider our concerns and take action to protect the environment and the community. Sincerely, Fred Stine, Community Action Coordinator at the Delaware Riverkeeper Network.”
Ms. Milian said that the discussions surrounding the Schedler property have pegged sports people against non-sports people. Ms. Milian stated that she has played sports her entire life, loves sports, and wants to see her children involved in sports. However, she stated that it is not about sports, but it is being “pegged” that way because of the Village Council.
Mayor Vagianos announced that the next speaker would be the last one to speak before taking remote access calls. Councilmember Reynolds stated that Mr. Damiano cut in line without the permission of some people waiting in line, and it was not fair for the tenth person who was waiting in line to not be able to speak at this portion of public comments. Councilmember Weitz stated that the people waiting in line would have the first opportunity to speak during public comments at the end of the meeting.
Jacqueline Hone, 30 Carriage Lane, said that Mayor Vagianos had promised that extra time would be allotted to allow time for everyone to speak when there was a “hot topic” being discussed and many people wanted to make public comments. However, Ms. Hone stated that Mayor Vagianos once again was going back on his word and she was very disappointed.
Ms. Hone stated that the adverse effects of the proposed development at Schedler Park have been brought to the attention of the Village Council on numerous occasions. She said there is no question that there will be adverse effects on groundwater resources. Community water supply wells are located within 500 feet of the proposed turf field. Currently, the well water is not affected because there are seven acres of trees that have been helping to filter out any pollutants from the water; however, it will be affected by the proposed turf field and clearing of the trees. Air quality will also become an issue if the trees currently on the property are razed and can no longer filter out air pollution and roadway pollutants. The resultant air quality issues will further cause adverse respiratory and cardiovascular health problems. Ms. Hone wondered how the Village Councilmembers could possibly vote on a plan, which they know will adversely affect the surrounding community, and park visitors.
Ms. Hone stated that studies have proven that there are links between noise pollution and health. She said that evidence has been presented to the Village Council, which proves that removal of the trees on the Schedler property will increase noise levels in the area. She stated that evidence has also been provided to the Village Council regarding the health risks caused by PFAS and artificial turf. Ms. Hone stated that the proposed plans will adversely impact the local wildlife habitats and threatened and endangered species, especially by the proposed 60-foot netting. She said that no traffic pattern studies have been performed and there has been no due process for residents. Ms. Hone stated that she assumed the Village Councilmembers are rushing to approve the plans for the Schedler property because the window for grant applications is closing. She said that before any grant applications are submitted, there must be public involvement in the planning process through the means of a public hearing.
Robert Lynch, 40 Sherwood Road, said that he has lived in Ridgewood for over 20 years and is a longstanding member of the Ridgewood Lacrosse Association’s Board of Trustees. On behalf of over 700 participants in the Ridgewood Lacrosse Association’s youth programs and over 200 athletes at the high school level, Mr. Lynch said that he wanted to underscore the continuing and increasing need in the Village for reliable field space. Both children and adults are encouraged to be more active and less sedentary, but Mr. Lynch said that encouragement is not enough. The Village needs to invest in its infrastructure to support these endeavors. More full-sized, multipurpose sports fields are needed in Ridgewood. Mr. Lynch said that the recent introduction of the girls’ flag football program at Ridgewood High School has significantly reduced access to available playing fields, by young lacrosse athletes.
Suzanne Ruane, 705 Kingsbridge Lane, stated that she supports a small grass field on the Schedler property and objects to the proposed large-sized turf field. She said that people who do not live near the Schedler property will not be subjected to the pollutants, contaminated water, constant highway noise, health hazards and dangerous traffic that will arise if the current development plans for the property are approved by the Village Council. People who do not live near the property will be able to go home after a game and drink clean water, breathe clean air, and sleep without highway noise, unlike the neighbors who live near the Schedler property. Ms. Ruane said that the Schedler neighbors have huge concerns regarding their health and traffic. She said that the exit ramp off Route 17 onto West Saddle River Road has no signage or warnings for cars to slow down.
Ms. Ruane stated that a traffic study was performed by the Ridgewood Police Department on West Saddle River Road between June 25 and August 10, 2015. This study revealed that cars exiting the highway continued traveling at high speeds once they were on West Saddle River Road (82% in June and 92% in August). In addition, the study revealed that 58% of cars in June and 66% of cars in August were traveling above 30 miles per hour, with 26% of cars in June and almost 30% in August that were traveling over 35 miles per hour. Ms. Ruane indicated that the neighbors surrounding the Schedler property have repeatedly requested that a more comprehensive traffic study be conducted, by an independent evaluator, before the plans are approved for this property. The study conducted by the Ridgewood Police Department was done at a time when schools were out for the summer and families were away on vacation. The Schedler neighbors are requesting that a new traffic study be performed while schools are in session and parents are not on vacation, so that more accurate data can be obtained. Ms. Ruane said that it was “a tragedy waiting to happen” if the Village Council gives approval for the construction of a major sports complex, next to a highway, without any safety precautions being established.
Leo Ruane, 705 Kingsbridge Lane, stated that he supports a small grass field on the Schedler property and objects to a full-sized turf field. He said that the neighbors near the Schedler property are concerned that adequate due diligence has not been performed by the Village Councilmembers and that there is no transparency to the public regarding this matter. He said that the reasons for reopening the plans for the Schedler property have never been adequately explained to Village residents or backed up by facts or statistics that demonstrate a change in demand or need for these changes, from the original 2017 plans. The original plans were developed by an Ad Hoc Committee and feedback and discussions with residents and the Village Council. The plans were revised solely by the Village Councilmembers, without any input from Village residents. While residents have brought up their concerns before the Village Council, these concerns have never been adequately addressed.
Mr. Ruane said that several questions were raised several weeks ago by his neighbor, Matt Rossi, which need to be answered by the Village Engineer, but no answers have been forthcoming. Without due diligence and transparency on the part of the Village Council, Mr. Ruane stated that there should not be a vote or adoption of a plan for the Schedler property. He asked that the Village Engineer provide the requested answers.
The questions are: 1) As the Village Council has asked to increase field size, do you feel confident your engineering team can adequately navigate all health, historic, safety, wildlife, and traffic concerns in redesigning this space? 2) If not, what is your suggestion for areas where the Village should source independent experts? 3) What would you estimate grading depth would be for a larger field? 4) Is the Engineering Department taking into consideration the results of a 2019 Phase 1A archaeological assessment of the Zabriskie-Schedler house and property during these redesigns and potential grading? 5) If a turf field is installed, are you considering potential contamination to surrounding private wells? 6) What testing would be needed for a turf field? Collection tests sometimes require 150,000 gallon holding tanks be tested. If we need this, how do we accommodate this? 7) Collection during four months will further narrow West Saddle River Road. Do you think added traffic during these times would be problematic? 8) What logic are you using when calculating ratio of field size to designated parking, and do you feel confident making these calculations? 9) Can you outline what areas would have significant cost increases when considering a larger field? 10) Now that the town has flood insurance on the property, are there flood implications to the neighborhood with the new site plan and demolition of more trees?
Mr. Ruane stated that no plan should be adopted until the answers to these questions are received from the Village Engineer.
Ankit Dharia, 471 West Saddle River Road, said that he moved to Ridgewood about nine months ago with his family. One of the reasons they moved to Ridgewood was because of its historic nature, great schools, and sports opportunities. Mr. Dharia feels that for the past three months, regarding the development of the Schedler property, the tone has been “us against them.” He wants the Village residents to think as a community regarding the safety of all residents, young and old. He has witnessed drivers speeding over 50 miles per hour on West Saddle River Road, and there was a car accident in this area about two weeks ago. Mr. Dharia urged the Village Council to address all of the concerns raised by Mr. Ruane, most concerning safety and health, so that a proper decision is made regarding the type and size of the proposed field.
Lan Shen, 147 West Glen Avenue, stated that she objects to a full-sized turf field, because she feels that it is unsafe and is not a “need” but a “want.” There are six elementary schools, two middle schools and a high school in Ridgewood, all equipped with decent-sized fields. There is also a field at Citizens Park, Veterans Field, and others. Ms. Shen asked why the Village could not find ways to utilize these existing spaces instead of damaging the environment and installing a turf field that will be toxic and harmful to children. She feels that it would be better to build a park with a playground and a small field, while prioritizing items that enhance safety in the Village, such as constructing sidewalks on West Glen Avenue.
Ms. Shen said that she has two elementary school-aged children who always want to bike to and from school and nearby parks; however, they are not allowed to do so, because it is not safe without sidewalks. She said that it is not safe to bike or even walk along certain sections of West Glen Avenue without a sidewalk. She urged the Village Council to prioritize the sidewalk project rather than allocating funds for a full-sized turf field.
Denise Lima, 319 East Glen Avenue, said that there is information readily available online from the New Jersey Department of Transportation regarding safety. This information includes updated yearly data and statistics on safety rates, crashes, injuries, and fatalities, broken down by mileposts. Along Route 17, from milepost 17 to milepost 1869 (1.4 miles), there were 91 crashes along this stretch of highway (500 feet of which is composed of the Schedler property). This total has increased almost 21% over the last five years. Ms. Lima said that this is a very dangerous section of the highway and the Village Council should take some time to consider where the entrance to Schedler Park should be, since many people exiting the highway continue speeding on West Saddle River Road. She suggested that another Ad Hoc Committee be formed to investigate the safety aspects of the proposed development of the Schedler property.
Christine Corbett, 405 Heights Road, said that she lives close to the section of West Glen Avenue where there are no sidewalks. She feels that the construction of sidewalks should be prioritized by the Village Council, instead of constructing a giant turf field at the Schedler property. Ms. Corbett feels that the trees should remain, and that the smaller field, which was originally planned, should be constructed. She is not sure whether it should be turfed, but feels that the less turf there is, the better. She urged the Village Council to reconsider the original plans. When her daughter was playing soccer years ago, there did not seem to be an excessive shortage of fields in Ridgewood.
There were no further public comments.
6. VILLAGE MANAGER’S REPORT
Ms. Mailander stated that “Council Chat” is held the first Saturday of every month from 9:00 A.M. to 11:00 A.M. The next “Council Chat” will be held on Saturday, May 6, 2023 in the Village Hall courtroom. Individuals interested in speaking with Village Councilmembers should call 201-670-5500, extension 2207, to make a reservation. Walk-ins are welcome, but those with reservations will have priority.
Ms. Mailander said that yard waste collection has begun. Residents should check the Village calendar for their collection area.
The Health Department will be hosting an educational program on Tuesday, April 18, 2023 from 1:00 A.M. to 2:00 P.M. at the Ridgewood Public Library Auditorium, dealing with the subject of “What Exactly is a Care Manager?” Tiffany Ewell, Care Manager with Caring People Home Healthcare, will explain what care managers do, how they do it, why it is beneficial to have one, and how to pay for one. Light refreshments will be provided. Registration is required. Interested individuals should call the Ridgewood Health Department at 201-670-5500, extension 2313.
The Health Department will also be hosting its annual Dog Rabies Clinic at the Graydon Pool parking lot on Wednesday, May 3, 2023, from 6:00 P.M. to 7:00 P.M. Dogs should be leashed. It will be a drive-by clinic. All dogs seven months or older must be licensed. Dog license renewals will be sent out via email during the last week of April. Renewals are due before June 30, 2023 to avoid a late fee. Interested individuals should contact the Health Department for more information.
The Kasschau Memorial Shell is celebrating its 65th anniversary. Everyone is encouraged to help celebrate this landmark on April 19, 2023, all day at Steel Wheel Tavern. Twenty percent of all proceeds from lunch and dinner will be donated to the Kasschau Memorial Shell. There will be live music with Joe Oriente and Lisa Grace from 5:00 P.M. to 6:30 P.M.
Online registration is now open for the purchase of badges for Graydon Pool, tennis and pickleball. Discounted rates are available through April 30, 2023 for Ridgewood residents (adults and children). Visa or MasterCard is accepted and there will be a 3% convenience fee charged. Pre-season badge distribution or in-person assistance will be available at the Graydon Pool office on April 12, at the Lester Stable on April 17 from 4:30 P.M. to 7:00 P.M., and at Graydon Pool on May 14 and May 21 from 10:00 A.M. to 12:00 P.M. For the 2023 season, families may now purchase a babysitter badge for $195.00. This badge can be used by live-in nannies, au pairs, multiple daily babysitters over the age of 18 or grandparents caring for the child that day. Those in possession of the babysitter badge may not enter the facility unless accompanied by the child badge holder and are not permitted to bring guests at any time.
The Opening Day Parade for the Ridgewood Baseball and Softball Association (RBSA) will be held on April 22, 2023. It will begin at 9:00 A.M. at the Ridgewood Train Station, continue down Ridgewood Avenue to Maple Avenue, and culminate at Veterans Field. This will be a fun day for the entire family with bounce houses, vendors, and food trucks. All are welcome to attend.
The Annual Earth Day and Daffodil Festival will be held on Sunday, April 23, 2023 from 11:00 A.M. to 2:00 P.M. This family-friendly event will include a petting zoo, eco-friendly kids’ crafts, games and live music. Ridgewood Water will have a table presenting “Journey from Rain to Drain” via displays and printed materials. There will also be a Daffy Dog Parade for costumed dogs and their owners at 12:30 P.M. (participants must register by 12:00 noon). Prizes will be awarded for exceptional costumes.
Ms. Mailander reminded everyone that the two day per week irrigation restriction is currently in effect. Odd-numbered addresses may irrigate on Tuesdays and Saturdays, and even-numbered addresses may irrigate on Wednesdays and Sundays. No irrigation is permitted on Mondays, Thursdays or Fridays.
Ridgewood “Learn to Ride and Safe Skills” bicycle course will be held on May 13, 2023 at the Graydon Pool parking lot. Children can learn how to ride a bike with a “balance first” approach. Instructors will teach children how to balance and control their bikes with the pedals removed, and will also teach basic safety skills. Learn to Ride Session 1 for children ages 5 and over will be held from 9:00 A.M. to 10:00 A.M. The Safe Bike Skills Course for children in grades 3-11 will be held from 10:15 A.M. to 11:45 A.M. Learn to Ride Session 2 for children ages 5 and over will be held from 12:00 P.M. to 1:00 P.M. The cost is $15.00 for Ridgewood residents and $30.00 for non-residents. Interested individuals may register at Community Pass at www.ridgewoodnj.net/communitypass and should only sign up for one session before May 5, 2023.
Ms. Mailander indicated that the 2023 Wellness Series will promote healthy eating, exercising, financial literacy, environmental sustainability, mental health, reducing stigma, and increasing social support. As part of the wellness events, the Parks and Recreation Department is offering “Chill Out – Gentle Yoga” on Mondays in May from 1:30 P.M. to 2:15 P.M., and “Fishing to Clear the Mind” on Saturday, May 29th, with two sessions to choose from: 9:30 A.M. to 11:30 A.M. or 12:20 P.M. to 2:30 P.M. Interested individuals should register via Community Pass.
Upcoming Village Council meetings are broadcast live from the Village Hall Courtroom, on the Village website, on FIOS Channel 34 and YouTube. The next Public Meeting is scheduled on May 10, 2023 at 7:30 P.M. The next Village Council Work Sessions will be held on April 26, May 3 and May 24, 2023 at 7:30 P.M. A Budget Hearing and Adoption Meeting will be held on April 27, 2023 at 7:30 P.M. All meetings will have hybrid access (in person, Zoom or phone).
8. VILLAGE COUNCIL REPORTS
Councilmember Weitz said that he was going to waive giving his report this evening, given that there are many people attending the meeting this evening waiting to speak and waiting to hear the vote regarding the Schedler project. He suggested the other Village Councilmembers follow his lead.
Councilmember Winograd said that she grew up in Ridgewood and went to Ridgewood High School. The first time she spoke before the Village Council was when there was a proposal to suspend all on-street parking around the high school, and she lost her composure while speaking publicly, because it was such an important issue. She said that she was impressed with young Lauren Bond, who spoke earlier this evening.
On April 4, 2023, Councilmember Winograd met with the Fields Committee and the discussion centered mostly on the Schedler property. Several sports groups’ members attended the meeting and they expressed their need for more playing fields in the Village. They reviewed the opening of the restrooms at Veterans Field and the pilot rollout of Master Library, a software program for scheduling fields and facilities. There was also a discussion about adult sports play being scheduled. Several adult residents of Ridgewood expressed their desire to be recognized within the fields policy as having the right to utilize and play on Village fields, since the vast majority of fields are used by children. Adult recreation includes a women’s softball team and a men’s soccer league.
On April 11, 2023, Councilmember Winograd met with the Shade Tree Commission in the Garden Room. Matthew Rogers, Village Attorney, was present at the meeting. Carolyn Jacobi is the new Chair of the Shade Tree Commission. The meeting was very productive, and the discussion mentioned that shade trees will be featured in the 2024 Village calendar. They discussed additional sources of revenue and a possible “Adopt a Sapling Day” and Earth Day. By-laws were adopted and will be posted on the website. The Schedler property was also a subject of discussion, with members concerned about the dead trees on the berm, which were intended to serve as a buffer from Route 17.
On April 12, 2023, Councilmember Winograd attended a function at the Ridgewood Public Library with Deputy Mayor Perron, where the Friends of the Library held their annual Author Luncheon. Councilmember Winograd expressed gratitude to this group for all of their efforts in enhancing the programming at the library.
On the weekend of April 15th, the Ridgewood Guild is holding a pop-up sale on Ridgewood Avenue at a vacant storefront next to Bare Burger. All items will cost under $50.00. This will also give interested individuals an opportunity to examine the interior layout of this now-vacant retail store.
Councilmember Reynolds began by apologizing to all residents that there was a cutoff during the early portion of this evening’s public comments. The Project Pride Committee met on April 10, 2023. There are several new members, and the meeting was robust, with many new ideas set forth. The Project Pride Sunflower Award will be given out again this year, towards the end of June. Six awards will be given out every two weeks. Five awards will be given to residents and one award will be given to a business in the CBD. It is hoped that these awards will give shop owners the impetus to promote beautiful designs on their front doors and façade. This year, the awards will be accompanied by a $25.00 gift card from 36 different Village businesses. Councilmember Reynolds said that Mr. Damiano, who spoke earlier this evening, was instrumental in organizing this initiative and getting approval from the Ridgewood Guild. The annual plantings in the CBD will be held on May 21, 2023. Volunteers who wish to participate should email Councilmember Reynolds at lreynolds@ridgewoodnj.net. This is a short time commitment of two to three hours, on Sunday morning.
The Kasschau Shell Committee met on April 5, 2023. They are having a fundraiser at Steel Wheel Tavern on April 19, 2023. Glenn Carlough, the owner of Steel Wheel Tavern, has pledged to donate 20% of all proceeds from lunch and dinner to support the Kasschau Shell. There will be live music from 5:00 P.M. to 6:30 P.M. with Joe Oriente and Lisa Grace, and more live music following their performance.
The Citizens Safety Advisory Committee will be meeting on April 20, 2023 at 7:30 P.M. in the Garden Room.
Councilmember Reynolds announced that the Village Council will be voting this evening on two very controversial items: the Schedler project and the hiring of an historic preservation specialist for the Schedler property. She stated that she feels her Village Council colleagues are being hypocritical in their thinking. There were Proclamations read this evening regarding Tree Planting Month, National Drinking Water Week, and No Mow May, and ordinances are being introduced to charge Village residents a PFAS treatment surcharge and to amend Chapter 269 regarding the times during which Smart Controllers may be used, to encourage water conservation. Councilmember Reynolds said that the Village’s commitment to remove PFAS from the Village drinking water is a $100 million project. A Shared Services Agreement is being authorized with Glen Rock and Washington Township for use of the Village-owned Styrofoam densifier, which will save space in landfills and create building materials from the densified Styrofoam.
The Village Council is also supporting the Green Amendment, which supports the inalienable rights of all people (including all residents on both the east and west sides of the Village) to have safe drinking water, clean air, a healthy environment, and preservation of the natural scenic, historic, and aesthetic qualities of the environment. However, Councilmember Reynolds said that if the proposed Schedler plans, as currently presented, are approved by the Village Council this evening, these inalienable rights will be taken away from Village residents. She said that nothing will be left on the Schedler property except a field. Councilmember Reynolds said that the neighbors living near the Schedler property need trees to protect them from Route 17. She disagreed with Mr. Muller’s previous statements that neighborhood children playing in their backyards near the Schedler property is the same as playing on the Schedler property itself, which abuts Route 17. Councilmember Reynolds said that the trees which were on the Schedler property provided an efficient buffer for the residents residing in that area.
Councilmember Reynolds announced that a donation is being accepted this evening for the planting of trees at a beautiful site called “Linda’s Grove” in honor of Ridgewood resident, Linda McNamara. She stated that all of the initiatives this evening are environmentally friendly, yet the Village Council’s approval of the Schedler plan this evening will be in stark opposition to these environment-enhancing projects. Hundreds of trees will be torn down and residents’ rights to clean air, safe drinking water, preservation of the natural, scenic, historic and aesthetic qualities of the environment will be harmed. She said that her colleagues should remember the historical events that took place on the Schedler property.
Councilmember Reynolds said that everyone on the dais “talks the talk” but needs to “walk the walk.” She said that they have to stop destroying every square inch of open space. She said that squeezing a large field onto this property will create encroachments and will leave no surrounding open space. She stated that the wildlife (including bald eagles and black-crowned night heron on the endangered species list) and habitats, as well as the quality of life of the Schedler neighbors, need to be preserved. Councilmember Reynolds said that the Village Councilmembers need to turn down a large turf field, which will contaminate residents’ well water with PFAS, and vote against the removal of hundreds of trees. She feels that the Village Council should honor the agreed upon plans developed in 2018.
Deputy Mayor Perron stated that Easter in the Park was “glorious” this past weekend, which was sponsored by the Chamber of Commerce. She and Margie Downs passed out chalk to children to draw on the sidewalk by Memorial Park at Van Neste Square. She mentioned that someone wrote on the sidewalk, “Thanks! This was fun – do it again next time!” This was the first year since the Covid pandemic that an Easter egg hunt could be held.
Green Ridgewood is gearing up for the Earth Day Fair and the Daffodil Festival to be held on April 23, 2023. The theme is the new Master Plan, and there will be various exhibits educating people about the Master Plan and how it will be implemented. Deputy Mayor Perron encouraged everyone to attend.
Deputy Mayor Perron stated that the Schoolhouse Museum is one of Ridgewood’s “gems.” It is an historical repository of memorabilia of events that occurred in Ridgewood and Bergen County. The museum is celebrating its 150th anniversary, and the Ridgewood Historical Society and Schoolhouse Museum are holding a fundraising dinner/dance gala on May 18, 2023 from 6:30 P.M. to 10:30 P.M. at Felina. Interested individuals may obtain tickets at ridgewoodhistoricalsociety.org.
Some Green Ridgewood members attended the Bergen County Public Hearing where they discussed the Master Plan for Bergen County. Their Master Plan was approved, and Green Ridgewood will be reviewing the environmental guidelines contained within the Bergen County Master Plan and comparing it with Ridgewood’s newly adopted Master Plan.
The Central Business District Advisory Committee (CBDAC) will meet on April 13, 2023 at 8:30 A.M. in the Senior Lounge at Village Hall. They will be discussing the Chamber of Commerce’s new Five-Year Strategic Plan. All members of the public are welcome to attend.
Deputy Mayor Perron stated that the Author Luncheon held at the Ridgewood Library was very meaningful, and many topics were discussed, such as horseracing and the Civil War. She encouraged everyone to attend this event next year.
Mayor Vagianos attended Easter in the Park with his three-year-old granddaughter. Joan Groome, Executive Director of the Chamber of Commerce, hid over 10,000 Easter eggs with candy in them for the children to find in Memorial Park at Van Neste Square. He said that over 1,000 people attended this event and it was wonderful.
Mayor Vagianos announced that the YMCA is holding their Annual Fundraising Gala on April 27, 2023. Mayor Vagianos said that he will be attending, and he urged everyone to buy tickets online for this event. Proceeds will benefit YMCA programs.
Mayor Vagianos stated that he attended a Chamber of Commerce meeting this morning, and they are in the throes of holding board and officer elections. Their installation dinner will be held at Steel Wheel Tavern on June 13, 2023.
Mayor Vagianos said that the Stigma-Free Committee is a wonderful group, and they will be holding a Stigma-Free symposium focused on mental health on May 3, 2023 at 8:30 A.M. at Biaggio’s. They will also be holding a “Unity in the Community” event at Overpeck Park on July 29, 2023. On April 19, 2023 from 8:30 A.M. to 4:30 P.M., this committee is holding a Mental Health Symposium for First Aid and First Responders at the firehouse in Ridgewood. Anyone interested in attending any of these programs should consult the Village website (under the Health Department tab) for further information.
Mayor Vagianos announced that Dylan Hanson, Director of Ridgewood’s IT Department, is celebrating his 47th birthday. There was a resounding round of applause.
9. ORDINANCES – RIDGEWOOD WATER
A. PUBLIC HEARING - #3945 – AMEND CHAPTER WATER RATES AND PFAS TREATMENT SURCHARGE
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3945 by title on second reading and that the Public Hearing thereon be opened. Deputy Mayor Perron seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3945 by title only:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 145 OF THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD, FEES, AT SECTION 145-6, “ENUMERATION OF FEES RELATING TO CODE CHAPTERS”
Mayor Vagianos opened the Public Hearing on Ordinance #3945. There were no public comments, and Mayor Vagianos moved that the Public Hearing be closed. Deputy Mayor Perron seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Councilmember Weitz moved that Ordinance #3945 be adopted on second reading and final publication as required by law. Deputy Mayor Perron seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
B. CONTINUED PUBLIC HEARING - #3940 – AMEND CHAPTER 269 – WATER – SMART CONTROLLERS AND WATER EMERGENCIES
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3940 by title on third reading and that the Public Hearing thereon be continued. Councilmember Weitz seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3940 by title only:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 269 OF THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD, WATER, AT ARTICLE IV: IRRIGATION SCHEDULE AND WATER EMERGENCIES
Mayor Vagianos stated that the Village Council continued the Public Hearing on Ordinance #3940 from the March 8, 2023 Public Meeting to this evening, so that questions about the Smart Controllers could be answered. Ordinance #3940 was discussed at the March 22, 2023 Work Session and the Village Council agreed that under the “ADD” portion in Section 269-48E, the wording “on the permissible day” should be deleted and should read as follows: “Irrigation shall not be conducted between 10:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m. on any day. Irrigation using automatic systems, including Smart Controllers, may only be used between 3:00 a.m. and 7:00 a.m.” Since this is not a substantive change to the ordinance, Mayor Vagianos asked for a motion to amend Ordinance #3940, as previously stated.
Deputy Mayor Perron moved that Ordinance #3940 be amended as stated by Mayor Vagianos. Councilmember Weitz seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Mayor Vagianos continued the Public Hearing on Ordinance #3940, as amended. There were no public comments, and Mayor Vagianos moved that the Public Hearing be closed. Councilmember Weitz seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Deputy Mayor Perron moved that Ordinance #3940, as amended, be adopted on third reading and final publication as required by law. Councilmember Weitz seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
10. RESOLUTIONS – RIDGEWOOD WATER
Ms. Mailander indicated that the following resolutions, numbered 23-124 through 23-125, were to be adopted by a consent agenda and read by title only:
11. ORDINANCES
A. INTRODUCTION – #3942 – ADMINISTRATION OF GOVERNMENT
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3942 by title on first reading. Councilmember Weitz seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3942 by title only:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 3, ARTICLE II, OF THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD, ENTITLED “VILLAGE COUNCIL,” AT SECTION 5 ENTITLED “ANNUAL ORGANIZATION” AND SECTION 6 ENTITLED “MAYOR; DEPUTY MAYOR; PRESIDENT PRO TEMPORE.”
Deputy Mayor Perron moved that Ordinance #3942 be adopted on first reading and that May 10, 2023 be fixed as the date for the hearing thereon. Councilmember Weitz seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
B. INTRODUCTION – #3954 – AMEND CHAPTER 265 – VEHICLES AND TRAFFIC – NO STOPPING OR STANDING – VARIOUS WELL HOUSES
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3954 by title on first reading. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3954 by title only:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 265 OF THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD, VEHICLES AND TRAFFIC, AT SECTION 265-20, “NO STOPPING, STANDING OR PARKING” AND SECTION 265-66, SCHEDULE XVI: “NO STOPPING, STANDING OR PARKING”
Councilmember Reynolds moved that Ordinance #3954 be adopted on first reading and that May 10, 2023 be fixed as the date for the hearing thereon. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
C. INTRODUCTION – #3955 – AMEND CHAPTER 145 – FEES – FIRE DEPARTMENT FEES
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3955 by title on first reading. Councilmember Reynolds seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3955 by title only:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 145 OF THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD, FEES, AT SECTION 145-6, “FEES RELATED TO CODE CHAPTERS”
Deputy Mayor Perron moved that Ordinance #3955 be adopted on first reading and that May 10, 2023 be fixed as the date for the hearing thereon. Councilmember Reynolds seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
D. INTRODUCTION – #3956 – AMEND CHAPTER 133 – REFUSE CONTAINERS
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3956 by title on first reading. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3956 by title only:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 133 OF THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD, REFUSE CONTAINERS, AT SECTION 133-4, “APPLICATION FOR PERMIT; FEES; TERM; REGULATIONS”
Ms. Mailander pointed out that in the “ADD” portion of Section C, the word “dumpster” in the second and fourth paragraphs should be replaced with the word “refuse container.”
Councilmember Weitz moved that Ordinance #3956 be amended as discussed by Ms. Mailander. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Councilmember Weitz moved that Ordinance #3956 be adopted, as amended, on first reading and that May 10, 2023 be fixed as the date for the hearing thereon. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
E. INTRODUCTION – #3957 – AMEND CHAPTER 18 – GREEN RIDGEWOOD COMPOSITION AND MEMBERSHIP
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3957 by title on first reading. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3957 by title only:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 18 OF THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD, GREEN RIDGEWOOD COMMITTEE, AT SECTION 18-4, “COMPOSITION TERMS”
Deputy Mayor Perron moved that Ordinance #3957 be adopted on first reading and that May 10, 2023 be fixed as the date for the hearing thereon. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
F. PUBLIC HEARING - #3946 – ESTABLISH A CAP BANK
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3946 by title on second reading and that the Public Hearing thereon be opened. Councilmember Weitz seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3946 by title only:
CALENDAR YEAR 2023 - ORDINANCE TO EXCEED THE MUNICIPAL BUDGET APPROPRIATION LIMITS AND TO ESTABLISH A CAP BANK (N.J.S.A. 40A: 4-45.14)
Mayor Vagianos opened the Public Hearing on Ordinance #3946.
Laurie Weber, 235 South Irving Street, asked for an explanation of how the Village Council uses a Cap Bank. She is familiar with how the Board of Education uses one, since they have a 2% cap or limit on their tax levy, not including waivers. A tax increase of more than 2% will trigger the need for a vote. If the tax increase amounted to only 1%, the extra 1% could be added to the tax levy over the next successive three years. Ms. Weber said that she was unaware that the Village had a statutory limit of 2% regarding tax levies.
Ms. Mailander replied that this ordinance is adopted every year. She did not have all of the particulars, but stated that Robert Rooney, Village CFO, would get in touch with Ms. Weber to give her further information. Ms. Mailander stated that the Village can put aside up to 3.5% of the previous year’s final appropriations in the interest of promoting the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of Ridgewood.
There were no further public comments, and Mayor Vagianos moved that the Public Hearing be closed. Councilmember Weitz seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Councilmember Reynolds moved that ordinance #3946 be adopted on second reading and final publication as required by law. Councilmember Weitz seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
G. PUBLIC HEARING - #3948 – AMEND CHAPTER 26 – GREEN TEAM MEMBERSHIP
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3948 by title on second reading and that the Public Hearing thereon be opened. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3948 by title only:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 26 OF THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD, GREEN TEAM, AT SECTION 26-2, “PURPOSE,” AND SECTION 26-3, “MEMBERSHIP; TERMS OF OFFICE”
Mayor Vagianos opened the Public Hearing on Ordinance #3948. There were no public comments, and Mayor Vagianos moved that the Public Hearing be closed. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Deputy Mayor Perron moved that ordinance #3948 be adopted on second reading and final publication as required by law. Councilmember Winograd seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
H. PUBLIC HEARING - #3949 – AMEND CHAPTER 145 – FEES – PARKING RATES
Mayor Vagianos moved that the Village Clerk read Ordinance #3949 by title on second reading and that the Public Hearing thereon be opened. Deputy Mayor Perron seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
The Village Clerk read Ordinance #3949 by title only:
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 145 OF THE CODE OF THE VILLAGE OF RIDGEWOOD, FEES, AT SECTION 145-6, “ENUMERATION OF FEES RELATING TO CODE CHAPTERS”
Mayor Vagianos opened the Public Hearing on Ordinance #3949. There were no public comments, and Mayor Vagianos moved that the Public Hearing be closed. Deputy Mayor Perron seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
Councilmember Reynolds moved that ordinance #3949 be adopted on second reading and final publication as required by law. Deputy Mayor Perron seconded the motion.
Roll Call Vote
AYES: Councilmembers Perron, Reynolds, Weitz, Winograd, and Mayor Vagianos
NAYS: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
12. RESOLUTIONS – RIDGEWOOD WATER
Ms. Mailander indicated that the following resolutions, numbered 23-126 through 23-147, were to be adopted by a consent agenda and read by title only:
Regarding the Village’s Styrofoam densifier, which the Village’s Solid Waste Recycling Coordinator, Sean Hamlin, urged the Village to purchase, Mayor Vagianos stated that the densifier will now be part of a Shared Services Agreement with other municipalities, allowing the Village to recoup its investment in this asset. He invited parents to bring their children to the Recycling Center to speak with Mr. Hamlin to learn all about the Styrofoam densifier. Ms. Mailander encouraged everyone to bring Styrofoam to the Recycling Center and clarified that it is the hard Styrofoam found in packaging.
Ms. Mailander indicated that the following resolutions, numbered 23-148 through 23-149, would be considered separately and read in full:
Before voting on Resolution #23-148, Deputy Mayor Perron remarked that, every week, there is something in the news regarding artificial turf. This week, she read the report from the Federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regarding their “PFAS Strategic Road Map: EPA’s Commitment to Action 2021-2024.” Their introduction and conclusion stated that every level of government – Federal, Tribal, State and Local – needs to exercise increased and sustained leadership to accelerate progress to clean up PFAS contamination, prevent new contamination, and make game-changing breakthroughs in the scientific understanding of PFAS. Deputy Mayor Perron noted that in 2017 and 2018, none of the Village Councilmembers had ever heard about PFAS.
Deputy Mayor Perron stated that the report went on to say that the EPA’s decisions regarding PFAS will be grounded in scientific evidence and analysis. The current body of scientific evidence clearly indicates that there are real, present, and significant hazards associated with specific PFAS, but significant gaps remain related to the impacts of other PFAS on human health and in the environment. Regulatory development, at either the State or Federal level, would greatly benefit from a deeper scientific understanding of the exposure pathways, toxicities, and potential health impacts of less-studied PFAS.
Deputy Mayor Perron indicated that these are the reasons why she is in favor of building a grass field and dealing with artificial turf at a later date. She stated that just because PFAS is ubiquitous does not mean that the Village Councilmembers should throw their hands up and say, “Well, we can’t do anything about it.” Deputy Mayor Perron stated that the cosmetics and apparel industries are doing something about PFAS, and the Village Councilmembers now have an opportunity to do something about PFAS. She said that they owe this to the children and anyone who plays on the field at Schedler Park.
Deputy Mayor Perron remarked that there is a peer-reviewed article by Murphy and Werner in the Environmental Pollution Journal, which points out that not enough, is known about the harmful effects of PFAS. The EPA and Centers for Disease Control have set up registries around the country to track what effect PFAS might have on humans. Deputy Mayor Perron said that it could take years before these harmful effects come to light. She said that to obtain conclusive scientific evidence, a double-blind randomized study would need to be conducted, something which is not possible for the Village Council to do, since it would be unethical to conduct such a study with humans. She said that the data entered into the established registries is only entered after the harm has already happened, and she does not want to propagate the use of PFAS on her “watch.”
Deputy Mayor Perron stated that even if there weren’t public health issues at stake with the use of PFAS, there are certainly environmental issues. She stated that artificial turf is created in several layers, and many layers create an impermeable surface, which causes water runoff. The chemicals used in building the artificial turf leach into the groundwater, which creates unsafe drinking water. The useful life of artificial turf is eight to fifteen years, and then it must be disposed of in a landfill. She said that the Village is attempting to eliminate waste entering landfills by purchasing a Styrofoam densifier, yet some Village Councilmembers want to install an artificial turf field, thereby effectively adding more waste or “carpeting” to landfills, waste that will take many years to biodegrade.
In addition, Deputy Mayor Perron indicated that artificial turf is much hotter to play on than grass. The Master Plan has a “Heat Island Map of Ridgewood,” which indicates increased heat where the existing three artificial turf fields are located in Ridgewood. She said that she did not think it was wise to install yet another artificial turf field at the Schedler property.
Deputy Mayor Perron stated that if the 2018 plans for the Schedler property were interpreted as meaning that the Ridgewood community and Village Council agreed on a small artificial turf field, she said that things have changed in the ensuing five years. Today, more is known about the dangers of artificial turf to humans, fish, insects, and the environment. Anyone who thinks the Schedler property is dry land should bear in mind that the existing berm will prevent stormwater runoff from traveling over the berm and the water will revert onto the land. She said that the Village has not had good luck with artificial turf when it comes to flooding. For all of the reasons stated, Deputy Mayor Perron said that she was voting against Resolution #23-148.
Before voting on Resolution #23-148, Councilmember Reynolds said that she appreciated hearing all of the information given by Deputy Mayor Perron. Councilmember Reynolds said that she was surprised to hear the Village Councilmembers call the proposed field “a small-sided field.” She said that the field approved in 2018 was 50 yards by 75 yards, or 150 feet by 225 feet, which she stated was not really that small. She said that Christopher Rutishauser, Village Engineer, told the Village that if they approved the plans he originally presented a few months ago, he was certain that the plans would be approved by SHPO without having to go before the Historic Sites Council, enabling construction to be commenced and completed by the end of 2023. She has been told by representatives of SHPO that if the Village Council votes to have a larger-sized artificial turf field built on the Schedler property, it will delay the project completion by two to three years. Councilmember Reynolds said that this will still be the case even if Peter Primavera, the historic preservation specialist, is hired. She said that she would like to abide by the 2018 plan with the small-sided grass field and, for that reason, she is voting against the adoption of Resolution #23-148.
Before voting on Resolution #23-148, Councilmember Weitz remarked that there is no “win-win” regarding any decision made by the Village Council. However, he stated that he supports the larger turf field on the Schedler property. Regarding safety, he stated that once the turf field is built, there will be at least one athlete playing on the field wearing a uniform with Councilmember Weitz’s name on it. Councilmember Weitz said that he has reviewed the evidence presented regarding PFAS and feels that the evidence against the use of turf is inconclusive. He stated that all of the other towns where Ridgewood athletes play, have a turf field. He said that he does not hear anyone saying that those turf fields, including the three existing turf fields in Ridgewood, should be ripped out or that children should be prevented from playing on those fields. He said that he feels the argument that an artificial turf field does not need fertilizer, pesticides or water is valid. Councilmember Weitz stated that artificial turf fields are much safer after it rains, since divots are created on grass fields after it rains and athletes play on a wet field, creating greater chances of injuries.
Regard the historical aspect of the Schedler property, Councilmember Weitz stated that while he respects history, he feels that the Village Council needs to plan for the future. He said that generations of children will be playing on the Schedler field and it is a legacy that he is very comfortable leaving to future generations. It is undisputed that Ridgewood needs more playing fields, and also undisputed that the Schedler property was purchased by the Village to prevent developers from commercializing the property. Therefore, the property needs to serve the greater needs of the Village of Ridgewood. After many months of hearing arguments on both sides, Councilmember Weitz said that he has come to the reluctant but very strong conclusion that a large turf field is absolutely appropriate and needed at the Schedler property. He said that he will proudly vote in favor of Resolution #23-148.
Before voting on Resolution #23-148, Councilmember Winograd stated that she was sure everyone would agree that it was a good move by the Village to purchase the Schedler property, although the development of the land has lingered for way too long. She said that she has always supported the renovations to the Schedler house and the development of the Schedler property to include a field, walking path, and playground (which will satisfy the outstanding Green Acres diversion, which has affected her neighborhood since the 1980s, when a playground was inadvertently and unlawfully removed on South Broad Street).
Councilmember Winograd said that she was stunned that the conversation on the dais is not honest. She said that three and one-half acres of trees on the Schedler property have already been removed, not seven acres of trees. Before Councilmember Winograd and Councilmember Weitz were able to visit the property, the aforesaid trees had already been removed. She said that people move to Ridgewood because they love trees. She said that what the Village Council should do is take the extra $500,000.00 allocated in this year’s budget to “stuff” trees into the park wherever they will fit around the field. She said that the discussions have centered around the field and not the project in its entirety. Councilmember Winograd was surprised that the community was so surprised that the field would be made of artificial turf, when that was the original recommendation contained in the 2018 plans developed by the Ad Hoc Committee. She also wondered why the prior Village Council had not shepherded this project.
Councilmember Winograd said that the Schedler house is an important piece of the project. During her Village Council election campaign, she spoke about how the HealthBarn at Habernickel Park made that park so special. She acknowledged that, since her campaign, she has changed her mind about the size of the proposed field on the Schedler property. The main reason was the stress caused to children when fields in Ridgewood flood and are unusable, thereby causing practices and games to be canceled. She said that artificial turf fields can be cleaned faster and less expensively than grass fields, and that is appealing to her. Therefore, she stated that she fully supports adoption of Resolution #23-148.
Councilmember Winograd added that the withdrawal of the $40,000.00 donation from the Friends of the Historic Schedler House is a good lesson in project management. She said that whenever the Village accepts a donation from a group or organization, there needs to be full disclosure to the public about the funds received and how the funds will be used. Councilmember Winograd indicated that she would like the Village Councilmembers to address how the Zabriskie-Schedler house will be utilized, and asked that this item be placed on the next Work Session agenda for discussion.
Before voting on Resolution #23-148, Mayor Vagianos said that he was very happy to see so many children present at the meeting this evening, watching government at work and discussions regarding a “partisan, divided issue.” He said that he lives across the street from a playing field. He echoed Councilmember Weitz’s remark that the Village purchased the Schedler property to prevent a strip mall or gas station from being built and to construct a park, which can be utilized by the greatest amount of Ridgewood residents. Mayor Vagianos recalled the words of a softball coach who spoke before the Village Council, to the effect that he did not have enough fields to schedule all of his teams. Another coach stated that all of their practices take place at a facility in Waldwick, due to the unavailability of fields.
Regarding the trees on the Schedler property and residents’ concerns that more trees will be removed, Mayor Vagianos stated that most of the trees have already been removed. A few more will need to be removed to make way for the larger field. He stated that plenty of trees will be replanted on the property, wherever possible. Regarding PFAS, Mayor Vagianos referred to Deputy Mayor Perron’s use of the word “carpeting” (meaning artificial turf) that will be disposed of in landfills. He stated that the carpeting in the courtroom where this meeting is being held tonight has PFAS in it, and one day this carpeting will be disposed of in a landfill. He said that carpeting in homes also contains PFAS and will also one day be disposed of in a landfill. Mayor Vagianos asserted that the uniforms worn by young athletes also contain PFAS, as well as cooking utensils, food packaging, and dental floss.
Regarding the past unfortunate circumstances, which the Village has experienced with flooding on turf fields, Mayor Vagianos stated that this is the “main driver” for construction of the field on the Schedler property. He said that the existing three turf fields are located in a flood plain, but the Schedler property is not. When the turf fields flood, he said that it wreaks havoc on all of the children who play sports in the Village. For these reasons, Mayor Vagianos stated that he is in favor of adopting Resolution #23-148.
Before voting on Resolution #23-149, Councilmember Reynolds stated that the Village Councilmembers all took a pledge to serve and protect. A lot of information has been received regarding the reputation of Peter Primavera, and she has spoken to many people who relayed some terrible things about Mr. Primavera. Councilmember Reynolds feels that the Village Councilmembers have a duty to check and verify this information before hiring Mr. Primavera, stating that it would prove to be a tremendous embarrassment for the Village to hire him and later find out that this information is true. Councilmember Reynolds said that there have been many backup documents submitted to support some of this information. She feels that this item should be removed from this evening’s agenda until she had enough time to make some phone calls to verify the information that has been submitted. She feels that voting on this matter this evening will expose the Village to a lawsuit and will put the Village in harm’s way. She said that the Village Council is obligated to protect its residents. Therefore, Councilmember Reynolds indicated that she would be voting against Resolution #23-149.
Mayor Vagianos indicating that he was voting in favor of Resolution #23-149, because he feels that Mr. Primavera is the person who can help push the Schedler project forward. This project has languished for 14 years, during which time many Village Councilmembers have been elected.
Councilmember Winograd asked Ms. Mailander if the approved plans for the Schedler property could be posted on the Village website, and Ms. Mailander said that this will be done, if it has not already been posted on the website.
The Village Councilmembers took a brief three-minute break.
13. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Mayor Vagianos asked if there were any additional comments or questions from the public.
Laurie Weber, 235 South Irving Street, said that despite Mayor Vagianos’s comments regarding respect, she feels that residents who take the time to attend Village Council meetings to make public comments are treated badly. She likened public comments to a “cattle call,” where residents are forced to stand in line for hours because there is a limit placed on how many people can speak. She said that Mayor Vagianos could have made an exception to the time limit this evening, since there were many people who wanted to speak. However, Ms. Weber stated that Mayor Vagianos allowed Tony Damiano, someone who supports his views, to cut into the front of the line of people waiting to speak. She said that she arrived to the courtroom before 6:30 P.M. and still did not get the chance to speak because she missed the cutoff of ten people speaking at the beginning of the meeting.
Ms. Weber stated that it was mind-boggling that some Village Councilmembers are endeavoring to add PFAS back into the environment, while the Village struggles to mitigate the presence of PFAS in its water supply. She said that a lack of logic and conscience on the part of the Village Council is guiding them to further expose the community to PFAS. Mayor Vagianos has stated that PFAS is everywhere, in order to justify the construction of a turf field. Regarding Councilmember Weitz’s comment that there is inconclusive evidence that PFAS can create health hazards, Ms. Weber stated that he also counted his own children among the children who would be playing on this turf field at the Schedler property.
Ms. Weber stated that the National Academies of Science, Engineering and Medicine stated in a 2022 report that there was strong evidence that PFAS exposure, whether through ingestion, direct contact, or through the air, can lead to developmental problems in children, including increased cholesterol and kidney cancer. The EPA states that new restrictions on PFAS in drinking water will prevent thousands of deaths and prevent tens of thousands of serious PFAS-related illnesses. The New Jersey Department of Health recommended that athletes who play on artificial turf should perform aggressive hand and body washing after play, remove clothes inside out, and wash them separately to prevent further exposure to PFAS. Ms. Weber stated that this proves how dangerous PFAS exposure is. She wondered whether any of the Councilmembers knew any of these facts.
Ms. Weber stated that the law is very slow in catching up with science, regarding various health concerns. She said that it took many years for regulations to be enacted regarding asbestos, seatbelts, and cigarettes, at the expense of human life and health. She said that the Village Council majority is currently seeking to take advantage of the fact that there is not yet any law on the books banning artificial turf. She said that they will wind up “on the wrong side of history” for their actions. Ms. Weber said that she was pleasantly surprised to see Deputy Mayor Perron taking a stand against artificial turf. She thanked Deputy Mayor Perron for “stepping away from the herd.” She also thanked Councilmember Reynolds for championing the rights of Village residents.
Councilmember Weitz said that since he was elected to the Village Council, there has not been one meeting where the Schedler property has not been discussed. He said that the Village Councilmembers have heard many hours of meaningful and relevant public comments, and many Councilmembers have met privately with many residents. In addition, dozens of emails have been received and reviewed by the Councilmembers. Councilmember Weitz said that the allegation that the Village Councilmembers have not listened to the public is slightly disingenuous. He said that although they may not have the same opinions, it doesn’t mean that there is a “difference of respect” and that the Village Councilmembers are not listening to the public. However, he said that the Village Council meetings must be run in an orderly fashion and there are many matters that must be discussed, voted upon, and approved. Councilmember Weitz said that he fully supports Mayor Vagianos’s decision to abide by the time limits for public comments, especially so that the children attending this evening’s meeting could see the Village Councilmembers vote on the Schedler project. He said that the allegations of lack of transparency and treating people like cattle are unfair.
Joe DeMarco, 572 West Saddle River Road, stated that he was glad to finally hear each Village Councilmember’s stance on the Schedler property last week. However, he was disappointed that he was not given the opportunity to reply to their various stances before a vote was conducted. Addressing Councilmember Weitz, he stated that is where the difference lies. Dr. DeMarco said that he finds most of the justifications for a large multiuse turf field to be dismissive of facts, which have been presented by residents. He said that the Village Council’s “cherry-picked” consultant, Peter Primavera, has instructed the Village Council to stop all work on the Schedler project, including designing and voting, until he has been able to review all necessary information to make a recommendation to the Village Council. However, the Village Council has ignored Mr. Primavera’s advice and gone ahead and voted on the design for Schedler Park. In addition, the sum of $500,000.00 of taxpayer money has been allocated in this year’s budget towards the Schedler property, again without knowing all the necessary details to make an informed decision.
Dr. DeMarco said that, last month, a resident raised concerns about the use of Smart Controllers for lawn irrigation. A formal report was presented to the Village Council about water usage by customers of Ridgewood Water before they voted on the relevant ordinance this evening. He said that Village residents were not afforded the same basic rights as citizens of the Village of Ridgewood, regarding the Schedler property. He said that it is incumbent upon the Village Council to do their due diligence, to ensure the best outcome for all constituents.
Dr. DeMarco said that it has been over one month since he spoke before the Village Council about safety and traffic concerns for the neighbors living near the Schedler property. Dr. DeMarco said that the Village Engineer indicated to him that a new traffic study could be performed by the Ridgewood Police Department; however, this request was ignored by the Village Council. He said that the plans developed by the Ad Hoc Committee in 2017 came about through a detailed, thought-out process. A multitude of concerns were considered from all relevant groups, including field size, sound, preservation of history, safety and quality of life. He said that these criteria are no different today than they were back in 2017.
Dr. DeMarco stated that the original plans called for a 75 yard x 50 yard field positioned close to West Saddle River Road, with the preservation of many mature trees along Route 17. He stated this made sense, in order to protect children playing sports, by providing a canopy of protection. However, by enlarging the field and placing it as illustrated on Concept #24, these elements are gone. The original plans also called for 44 parking spaces. He said that the new approved plans do not allow for this many parking spaces, yet a larger field naturally brings a larger demand for parking.
Dr. DeMarco stated that the concerns raised by the Schedler neighbors should be shared by all Village residents. He said that the Schedler neighbors know what is best for their neighborhood, because they live there every day. They are familiar with the traffic patterns, including diversion of traffic onto West Saddle River Road after an accident occurs on Route 17, and the high speeds at which cars exit onto West Saddle River Road from Route 17. He said that these safety concerns need to be addressed for both the residents participating in sporting events at Schedler Park, and for the families who live in the Schedler neighborhood. Dr. DeMarco said that cars can barely pass each other on West Saddle River Road, especially when there are vehicles parked on each side of the road. Cars exiting from the Schedler property after a game will cause traffic jams, which the Schedler neighbors will have to deal with, every single day.
David Refkin, 401 Wastena Terrace, said that he is Chair of the Green Ridgewood Committee. The mission of Green Ridgewood is to assist the Village Council in long-range planning concerning environmental issues, to identify and anticipate environmental challenges, and to research and recommend sustainable solutions. Mr. Refkin said that the members of Green Ridgewood are a group of extremely dedicated and talented people. A lot of time is spent working on the above issues. Mr. Refkin said it was extremely disappointing that Green Ridgewood was not given the opportunity to speak this evening, in order to give their recommendations for the development of the Schedler property, before the vote was taken this evening.
Mr. Refkin said that he came to the meeting this evening at 6:15 P.M. and stood and waited for two hours, but did not get the chance to speak. He went home to rest for 40 minutes, and by the time he came back to the meeting, the vote had already been taken. Mr. Refkin said that since the last time members of Green Ridgewood addressed the Village Council on March 30, 2023, they have become aware of new research regarding artificial turf, which they feel is critical for the Village Councilmembers to evaluate before a decision and final vote is made. Mr. Refkin said that there is a growing body of evidence supporting the fact that artificial turf has serious public health, safety, and environmental problems.
Mr. Refkin said that everyone is aware of the ubiquitous nature of PFAS, which he stated was not a good thing. PFAS is used in the manufacture of artificial turf and it can be inhaled. PFAS bio-accumulates in the bodies of human. The EPA recently issued a directive stating: “Every level of government needs to exercise increased and sustained leadership to accelerate progress to clean up PFAS contamination and to prevent new contamination.” Mr. Refkin stated that, according to research conducted by Mount Sinai Hospital, women with high levels of PFAS in their blood have a 40% lower chance of becoming pregnant. This study, which was led by Dr. Nathan Cohen, stated: “Our study strongly implies that women who are planning pregnancy should be aware of the harmful effects of PFAS and should take precautions to avoid exposures to this class of chemicals.”
Mr. Refkin said that an article published in Time magazine on April 7, 2023 details legislation in nine states prohibiting the sale or distribution of various products due to PFAS and other chemicals. In one example, a bill was passed unanimously by the Vermont State Senate that includes a ban on artificial turf and many clothing products. Industry trade associations, such as the Outdoor Industry Association and the American Apparel and Footwear Association, support the Vermont bill. Mr. Refkin stated that private industry is presently supporting a ban on PFAS. He said that things are changing quickly.
Regarding crumb rubber, which is used as a key element in the foundation of artificial turf, Mr. Refkin stated that the New Jersey Institute of Technology completed a peer-reviewed study entitled “Health Impacts of Artificial Turf: Toxicity Studies, Challenges, and Future Directions.” The author of this study, Dr. Genoa Warner, stated: “Recent chemical analysis of crumb rubber, which is notoriously toxic, and of other artificial turf components, has identified hundreds of chemicals, including carcinogens, neurotoxicants, and endocrine disruptor chemicals.”
Mr. Refkin said that the emerging research, the recommendations from the U.S. EPA, the legislative action taken by nine states proposing a ban of PFAS, and serious fertility concerns are all sending everyone a clear signal. The U.S. EPA recently lowered its acceptable level of PFAS in drinking water by 94%. Ridgewood Water decided, before the NJDEP directives, to spend $100 million to reduce PFAS in the drinking water to non-detectable levels. Mr. Refkin stated that this is clearly a serious public health threat, and the Village should not be adding to the problem by installing artificial turf on the Schedler property. He said that based upon all of this new information, the Village needs to do everything in its power to dramatically reduce the exposure of PFAS to the public.
Mr. Refkin concluded by stating that Green Ridgewood believes that the proper course of action for the Village Council would be to install a natural grass field at the Schedler property. Children must be protected and the Village Council must heed the new information about the hazards of artificial turf, which cannot be ignored.
Rohan DeSilva, 521 West Saddle River Road, stated that it was true that residents did not want a 7-11 to be built on the Schedler property, but what they really wanted was a community garden and a playground on the property. He said that it did not seem to matter to the Village Council what people have repeatedly told them. He applauded Deputy Mayor Perron and Councilmember Reynolds on their stance against artificial turf. Mr. DeSilva said that he was very dismayed with Councilmember Winograd, Councilmember Weitz, and Mayor Vagianos for voting the way they did this evening regarding the Schedler property, asserting that they never listened to “their own people.”
Mr. DeSilva stated that he felt sorry for the young girl and her father who tearfully spoke this evening (the Bonds). He said that he himself, has compromised lung function (asthma) and he was certain that the lung function of his neighbors near the Schedler property has gone down, because so many trees were removed from the property to make way for the berm. Mr. DeSilva said that the Village Councilmembers have turned their backs on the residents and they need to start listening to Village residents and do what is right. He said that the Schedler neighbors care greatly about children as well, and do not want to see them develop cancer or reproductive issues 10 or 15 years from now, from playing on artificial turf.
Olivia Sakakihara, 172 West Glen Avenue, said that she has been at this evening’s meeting since 7:00 P.M. and is disappointed that she could not speak earlier. She said that it seems as though the Village has some money on hand to improve lives in the Village, and expressed the hope that some of these funds would be used to construct sidewalks for the children who live on West Glen Avenue. Ms. Sakakihara said that there are many children with special needs who live in this area. She said that there are many occasions when she cannot go outside for a walk with her son, because he sometimes requires a wheelchair. She said that going out for a simple walk is not a part of their reality.
Ms. Sakakihara said that, given all of the opposition to the large field at the Schedler property and numerous concerns of the residents, and in light of the great need for the construction of sidewalks on West Glen Avenue, she wished that priority would be given to something as basic as sidewalks. She said that residents have become divided into sports and non-sports people, but if everyone were concerned about the welfare of children, then they should think of safety first, and take care of other things at a later time. Ms. Sakakihara said that she first pays her mortgage, then buys food, and then thinks about a vacation. She stated that everyone has a pyramid of priorities, and she feels that such a pyramid of priorities is not well established in Ridgewood. She asked the Village Council to reconsider their priorities and allocate money for the construction of sidewalks on West Glen Avenue.
Aaron Greenberg, 570 West Saddle River Road, said that he is Joe DeMarco’s neighbor. He has a wife and three children: a 7-year-old daughter who plays four sports (soccer, lacrosse, gymnastics and T-ball); an 11-year-old autistic son who enjoys Rubik cubes, Roblox, and riding his bicycle outside; and a 3-year-old son. Dr. Greenberg said that he moved to Ridgewood because likes to have “elbow room” and liked the reputation of Ridgewood schools. They live in an historic home and have been gradually renovating it. All of the neighborhood children like to play outside and ride their bicycles in the nearby cul-de-sac. Dr. Greenberg said that he was worried about the safety of his children, and the other neighborhood children, with the volume of speeding traffic on narrow West Saddle River Road. He said that it was equally as dangerous on Bogert Road, and his SUV can barely fit through West Saddle River Road when there are vehicles parked on both sides of the street.
Dr. Greenberg said that he was equally as concerned about the noise, air pollution, and chemicals. He is an orthopaedic surgeon and treated many professional, college and high school athletes when he worked at the University of Texas. He performed a lot of arthroscopic knee surgery and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgeries. He himself has undergone multiple surgeries on both of his knees from injuries incurred while playing on artificial turf. Dr. Greenberg said that one can find data online to support pretty much anything; however, he told everyone anecdotally, from being in practice for many years, that turf fields produce lots of income for orthopaedic surgeons, since there are a lot more injuries incurred on turf fields than there are on grass fields.
Dr. Greenberg said that it would be wonderful to have a place to walk with his children, along with a playground on which they can play, and a small field for games at Schedler Park. He said that he really does not want a “large turf complex” near his house. He stated that he was also frustrated that he could not have spoken earlier in the evening, because he works a lot and barely has time to spend with his family.
Lynne Dewhurst, 176 West Glen Avenue, stated that she did not feel it was right that only 3-1/2 acres of old-growth trees remain on the seven-acre Schedler property. She said that in light of the many residents who have opposed the construction of a large turf field, and the obstacles that must be overcome with SHPO and other State agencies; she wondered why the Village Council would not reconsider the original plans developed in 2017. She asked that the Village Council reallocate funds designated for the Schedler property, to more important issues such as drainage and maintenance of Ridgewood’s numerous existing fields. Ms. Dewhurst asked who exactly will benefit from the clear-cutting of the trees on the Schedler property, the turf field, and the revision of the property’s historical significance, by an historian who is credibly alleged to have misrepresented his credentials for decades.
Ms. Dewhurst said that when she and her family moved to Ridgewood, there were only nine children living between North Monroe Avenue and Heights Road. However, there are now children residing in every single house, except one, along West Glen Avenue, ranging in age from two to twenty years of age. Several of these children have disabilities and a sidewalk is desperately needed along the entire length of the hill, as was planned, approved, and budgeted for in the past. She assumed that the start date of the Schedler project will probably be extended to 2024 and asked if, in the meantime, monies could be placed back in this year’s budget for the completion of the sidewalk construction on West Glen Avenue as a high priority, to enhance pedestrian and community safety.
Ms. Dewhurst said that West Glen Avenue is a highly trafficked road, with probably only 1 in 25 drivers obeying the speed limit of 25 miles per hour. She added that despite repeated requests to the Village, some of the speed limit signs were removed and never replaced on West Glen Avenue, including one sign that was knocked down by an Escalade at 4:00 A.M. in August 2022, near her home. She said that sidewalk construction took place in some sections of West Glen Avenue, but there remain stretches where sidewalks still do not exist. She said that the completion of the sidewalks would be a great accomplishment for the current Village Council, with the legacy of having made West Glen Avenue safer for pedestrians, bicyclists, dog walkers, wheelchair users, and stroller pushers. She urged the Village Council to reallocate monies toward the completion of the sidewalks as soon as possible, especially with the $500,000.00, which was allocated specifically for the Schedler property.
Saurabh Dani, 390 Bedford Road, thanked Councilmember Reynolds and Deputy Mayor Perron for their courage in voting against the Schedler plan, as well as the PFAS details provided by Deputy Mayor Perron. He said that Linda McNamara, a longtime Ridgewood resident who was opposed to turf fields, would be very proud of both of them.
Mr. Dani said that Deputy Mayor Perron is Village Council Liaison to the Green Team and Green Ridgewood. He said that at the last Village Council meeting, Deputy Mayor Perron raised some concerns about artificial turf. While Mr. Dani is not an expert on artificial turf, he asked the other Village Councilmembers whether they did any research on artificial turf after Deputy Mayor Perron raised her concerns. He wondered if the Village Councilmembers asked staff in the Health Department or any experts in this field, about their opinions regarding artificial turf and, if so, whether that information could be made public. If they did not, Mr. Dani said that the Village Councilmembers who voted in favor of the turf field ignored the concerns of Deputy Mayor Perron.
Mr. Dani said that Ridgewood Water is suing companies and manufacturers who contributed to the contamination of the Village’s drinking water with PFAS. He wondered how the statements made by the Village Councilmembers, who stated that they were not concerned about PFAS in artificial turf and who voted in favor of a turf field, would influence that litigation. He wondered if any of their statements would be used against the Village in that litigation.
Mr. Dani stated that the newly elected Village Councilmembers voted to alter the plans developed for the Schedler property in 2017. He asked what factors changed, since they ran for election, which led them to revise the plans, and why they broke their campaign promises. He asked whether they previously spoke to sports groups and whether they did their “homework” before making such promises.
Mr. Dani said that the Schedler project and the sidewalk project on West Glen Avenue are both capital projects. He said that no funds should be coming out of the Operating Budget for these projects and taxes should not be raised 4.3% due to these capital projects. He said this tax increase will perpetuate itself year after year. Mr. Dani said that there was no good reason why the sidewalk project should have been removed from this year’s budget. He wondered why a bond ordinance could not be done for the Schedler project and for the sidewalk project.
Mr. Dani concluded by stating that he has sent emails to the Village Councilmembers about some broken curbs in the Village. He received a response that the curbs will be fixed when the roads are resurfaced. He wondered why Village residents are forced to fix sidewalks or remedy hazards immediately, when the Village Council itself is not fixing broken curbs and putting it off until roads are fixed. Mr. Dani said that Mayor Vagianos’s statement that no more trees will be cut down on the Schedler property, is a misrepresentation, because if a large field is installed, there will not be enough room for bleachers or parking unless more trees are cut down.
Rurik Halaby, 1 Franklin Avenue, thanked the Village Council for “staying the course.” He asked that the Village Council start immediately to look for a new Village Manager. He said that having effective management at the highest level of Village government is critical. He said that he realizes the immense work this present Village Council must do, to undo the damage done by previous Village Councils over the past six years.
Regarding this year’s budget, Mr. Halaby asked that Mr. Rooney present the budget at a Town Hall meeting, with a “give and take” between Mr. Rooney and the public. He said that it is critical for the public to know how their taxpayer dollars are being spent. Mr. Halaby also asked that the Financial Advisory Committee (FAC) be reconstituted, since he feels that although the Village was able to “dodge the bullet” this year, it will not be able to be done next year.
Mr. Halaby said he reviewed a website pertaining to the Schedler property at schedlerpark.com and he could not locate any names on the website of the people who developed the website. He said that he has no time or respect for any website that does not disclose the people behind it. He wondered what these people are trying to hide. He said that this country has free speech, and if someone has something to say, they should say it, even if they get “booed,” because they are standing up for what they think is right. Mr. Halaby stated that this website consisted of half-truths, twisted facts, and exaggerated lies. He said that there was nothing credible on the website. For example, the website claims that citizens will be stripped of their right to a clean, safe, and healthy environment. He thinks that it is ridiculous to think that people will be stripped of their rights just because the Schedler plans were changed from a smaller to a bigger field. Other allegations are that history will be destroyed, a green ecosystem will be clearcut, and wildlife will be decimated.
Mr. Halaby said that he fully understood people’s fear of change and parents worrying about heavy traffic, but he said that there will be traffic whether there is a small or large field. He said the fear-mongering regarding the Schedler property is the same as the fear mongering which arose when the apartment complex (The Benjamin) was being discussed. There were fears that the Central Business District would be logjammed with traffic and that the schools would be overwhelmed with the additional children, who would be moving into those apartments. He lives at The Benjamin and he said there are only 16 children who reside in those apartments. Even though 16 more children were added to the school rolls, he said that students also left, at the same time. Mr. Halaby said that the fears proved to be unfounded.
In addition, Mr. Halaby stated that there was a fear that emergency vehicles, such as fire trucks, would be unable to put out a fire in the apartments. However, he said that this has never occurred.
Mayor Vagianos interrupted Mr. Halaby to say that the meeting is going to be ending at 11:00 P.M. and there were still people waiting to speak. He said that Mr. Halaby could cut his time short to allow these people to speak, or he could take the full five minutes.
Mr. Halaby concluded by facetiously stating that Councilmember Reynolds is becoming one of his favorite Councilmembers. Regarding the comments she has made on the dais, he wondered where she has been over the past six years, especially when they were building the disastrous berm at the Schedler property, which occupies one acre out of the seven acres. He wondered where she was when the property was used as a dump, for all of the dirt excavated to build the apartments (The Benjamin).
Ellie Gruber, 229 South Irving Street, stated that she was a member of the Schedler Ad Hoc Committee in 2017, when they were developing the plans for the Schedler property. Councilmember Winograd’s husband was also a member of the Ad Hoc Committee. She said that she wishes she took notes during the meetings. Former Mayor Hache, former Village Councilmember Michael Sedon, and others were present at the meetings. People familiar with soccer stated that baseball teams were losing a lot of players, but that there was a great need for a field on which young soccer players could play. Ms. Gruber said that she understood these comments, because there were three soccer enthusiasts on the Ad Hoc Committee. However, she said that they made a good point by stating that the field could be used by two teams of young soccer players at the same time, for both games and practices.
Ms. Gruber said that the members of the Ad Hoc Committee were well aware of the dangers of crumb rubber turf. Back in 2017, they consulted some environmental engineers regarding turf, but Ms. Gruber said that a lot has changed in the past six years and much more is known now about the hazards of turf. However, in 2017, the engineers recommended a coconut-based turf field so that the “little pellets” would not go astray. This type of turf field is what was recommended by the Ad Hoc Committee, not any other type of turf. Addressing Councilmember Weitz, Ms. Gruber indicated that cancer starts very early in life and comes to a head in later years. She said that she agreed with Deputy Mayor Perron that even if there were a chance of children developing cancer from the artificial turf, given the current information, she would not be willing to gamble on the lives of these children, as Councilmember Weitz appears willing to do. Ms. Gruber said that her orthopaedist is fully in favor of artificial turf, because he can make more money treating athletes who sustain injuries while playing on turf fields. Ms. Gruber concluded by stating that residents are planning to hire an attorney to fight the approved plans for the Schedler property, which she stated would end up being a very lengthy process. Ms. Gruber stated that the resolution passed in 2018, regarding the approval of the agreed upon plans, had a clause at the end, which stated that this resolution would be binding upon future Village Councils. However, Matthew Rogers, Village Attorney, has told Ms. Gruber that this clause “doesn’t mean spit.”
Regarding the withdrawal of the $40,000.00 donation by the Friends of the Historic Schedler House, Ms. Gruber stated that when these funds were originally offered, the Zabriskie-Schedler house renovations were nearly completed and this organization no longer needed their 501C3 bank account. They wanted to close this bank account, because they were certain that the house renovations would be completed, according to plan. The check for $40,000.00 was given to the Village with parameters as to how the money should be spent. However, the money was put in trust, because the house was not finished. Ms. Gruber said that the comments alleging that the money was donated with no directions given for how it was to be spent, are false. The organization said that the money could be used for constructing a kitchen or whatever was needed in the house.
Ms. Gruber said that accusing Councilmember Reynolds for the delay in completing the Schedler project is ridiculous. She stated that the main reason for the delay was a “runaway” Engineering Department. Ms. Gruber said that the staff in the Engineering Department “did their own thing” despite what the resolution said. The plans were not sent to the Village Council, but instead were sent to Nancy Bigos, Supervisor of the Parks and Recreation Department; Janet Fricke, then Assistant to the Village Manager; and to the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO). However, SHPO absolutely refused to approve these plans.
Frettra DeSilva, 521 West Saddle River Road, said that she was very disappointed in the decisions made by the Village Council this evening. She said that she expected government to act with logic and compassion, which has not occurred over the past several weeks. She said that humans learn through experience and by examining evidence that is placed before them. Ms. DeSilva stated that the Village Councilmembers have turned a “blind eye” towards very informative, scientific information and evidence. She said that residents have spoken before the Village Council and are standing up for their rights, currently and in the future. Ms. DeSilva indicated that the Village Councilmembers need to heed all of the information presently before them.
Jacqueline Hone, 30 Carriage Lane, said that she had questions regarding Resolution #23-148, which was approved by the Village Council this evening, regarding the approval of plans for the Schedler property. She said that this resolution was approved “on top of” the previously approved plans in 2018. It appears to her that there are now two standing plans for Schedler on the record at the current time. Ms. Hone felt that someone forgot to rescind the prior resolution, before adopting the resolution this evening. She asked for clarification from the Village Manager and Village Attorney what the next steps will be, given that there are now two resolutions pertaining to the Schedler property.
Ms. Hone said that the original plans indicated that the plans for the field were designated as a “final design,” but the resolution adopted this evening indicates that the plans are “conceptual design plans.” She said that the original 2018 plans were contingent upon various studies being performed. However, this new conceptual, but not final, plan appears to allow time for due diligence to be conducted and time for the Village Councilmembers to avoid breaching their fiduciary obligation to Village residents, by performing impact studies. Ms. Hone said that, contrary to the beliefs of the Village Councilmembers, they do not get to “cherry pick” what they want constructed on the Schedler property. She questioned why the Green Team, the Citizens Safety Advisory Committee, and Shade Tree Commission were not consulted regarding the development of this land.
Ms. Hone stated that specific questions were asked of Councilmember Weitz, but those questions were never answered, and he voted to approve the Schedler plans without addressing the concerns of Village residents. She said that the public is entitled to due process under the law, and a right to be involved in the planning process, including a public hearing. Despite numerous emails and public comments, Ms. Hone stated that residents are repeatedly ignored, if their concerns/wishes do not align with the personal agendas of the Village Councilmembers.
Ms. Hone said that everyone needs to pay close attention to the comments made by Mr. Dani this evening, especially to determine where the money is coming from in the budget for the Schedler capital project. She insisted that there is absolutely a way in which the sidewalks can be constructed this year on West Glen Avenue (via a bond ordinance). Ms. Hone said that it does not appear that the Schedler project will be completed anytime soon, especially since there is a Federal Migratory Act that protects trees from being razed until the month of August. She feels that the money allocated for the Schedler project this year should be reallocated to the sidewalk project, and also that the requested studies on the Schedler property be performed, before any more work is done on this property.
Alice Sienkiewicz, 321 Van Emburgh Avenue, said that she lived in New York City for 18 years and was a very active member in the Borough of Brooklyn. She would like to see everyone think about things logically, including the Village Councilmembers. She stated that the Village Council cannot talk about pro-green initiatives, yet think that these initiatives do not apply to them. She said that they either support a certain principle or they do not, but cannot go in between. She lives in a house built in the 1850s, and when she bought her home, there were no smoke detectors. However, there are now smoke detectors in the house, because the dangers of fire are well known. She said that when the Village Councilmembers insist that there is no evidence or not enough evidence against the hazards of artificial turf and environmental issues, the Village Council is not using logic. They should use logic in order not to cause further damage. She said that Councilmember Weitz’s comment that the Schedler neighbors are not thinking about the children, is very offensive to her. She said that everyone is thinking about future generations.
Mayor Vagianos closed public comments.
14. RESOLUTION TO GO INTO CLOSED SESSION
Ms. Mailander read Resolution #23-149 to go into Closed Session:
13. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Village Council, on a motion by Deputy Mayor Perron, seconded by Councilmember Weitz, and carried unanimously by voice vote, the Village Council’8 Regular Public Meeting was adjourned at 11:02 P.M.
____________________________________
Paul Vagianos
Mayor
____________________________________
Heather A. Mailander
Village Manager/Village Clerk
- Hits: 369