20220510 - Shade Tree Commission Meeting Minutes

STC – Shade Tree Update

Minutes from April 12, 2022 Meeting

Update on Bids planning for 2022 Planting

Follow ups from Meeting with Shade Tree Dept. Nancy Bigos and Chris Rutishauser

Agenda for Meeting May 10, 2022

May 10, 2022 (Corrections 1)

 

Meeting Minutes April 12, 2022

·       Terms for Members need to be finalized and sent to clerk’s office/Council

·       Tree Ordinance passed and went into effect May 3, 2022

·       We need to have a simple explanation of what is in the ordinance and get it out to residents and share with Dina as there will surely be confusion and resistance

·       Earth day successful. Carolyn to compile a list of possible improvements for 2023

·       Meeting with Village depts on April 13, 2022 scheduled - many issues to discuss

·       Need to work on outreach to residents as we have a strong story this year

·       Grants – grant money is available – we need a few members to take on the project and get application in

 

Update on Bids (what I know as of today)

·       EAB Removal and planting (Budget $219,000)

o   Removal bid for 107 trees is $179,000 ($1,672 per tree)

o   That leaves $40,000 for EAB re-planting

·       Street tree planting and large tree removal (contracted out) $300,000

o   $80,000 large trees

o   $220,000 for street planting (combined with EAB replacement $40,000) total $260,000.

·       CBD and Water Tanker (Budget $110,000)

o   Expect tanker $10,000 -$15,000)

o   CBD $95,000

·       CBD watering (22 trees) Tode bid lowest so far

o   $8,855 (23 weeks)

o   Filling 2 times a week ($385 per week, $195 per filling)

o   Bid not yet awarded

Issues raised at Meeting on April 13, 2022

·       CBD Many decisions to be made

o   What trees will be planted where?  Engineering concern that conduit in tree wells requires smaller trees to be planted.  STC perspective is that larger trees will provide more shade over time, which was a primary reason for recommending the planting.  Limited experience with conduit is that it is generally close to the curb and is protected. Large canopy trees are routinely planted in NYC and cities around the world so we should be able to develop an appropriate strategy. This needs to be resolved before the project is bid.

o   Declan to call PSEG for 3-4 test pit mark outs so we see what is actually in the wells.

o   Bid will include watering for 23 weeks for 1-2 years.  That will be expensive unless it can be done by Village staff.  (Based on Tode quote and assuming 75 trees planted could be $20,000+) so that reduces the # of trees that can be planted. No point in planting unless there is a watering plan.

o   Size of tree wells – Declan, Carolyn and I walked Ridgewood Ave and Broad.  I think we agreed that in the smaller wells should have at least one row of bricks removed (if there is enough sidewalk for ADA) so the wells can be bigger. 

o   How many trees to take out?  We discussed whether we should take all the trees that are in bad shape (but still have some leaves) or be a bit selective and leave some of the replacement for next year.  Issue is purely aesthetic/political as residents will likely be a bit surprised to see almost all the trees come down in the fall.  We should discuss this.  More efficient to do it all at once, risk of alienating residents.

o   Village arborist should have the final say on which trees go in which wells.

o   Engineering pointed out that if the Village is dissatisfied with a contractor’s work and does not want them to be considered for a future contract, the reasons for dissatisfaction must be documented.

o   Bid specifications need to be complete so bid can go out by July 1.

·       Fall planting

o   Bid specs to include species desired, stakes, water bags (with stickers), mulch.  Engineering may want to split the bid into smaller components of $44,000 to increase flexibility of the bidding process.

o   Need to follow up on source of water – Matt was going to talk the Water Dept.

o   Again, target July 1 for bid requests to go out.

Agenda for May 10,2022

·       Approve minutes from April

·       Review bids and #’s of trees

·       Discuss Tree ordinance communication to residents and social media in general

·       CBD issues

·       Carolyn reports Guild will donate to CBD planting (perhaps on Chestnut St?

·       Grants – will someone volunteer to work on them for this year and next?

·       New Business

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Some Basic Questions the STC and Parks and Shade Tree need to think about

 

1.   Tree Plan – Street Trees

We could be  working toward a comprehensive plan for the street tree canopy.  Things it could include for example are:

·       Years and frequency of watering after planting – how much does rainfall contribute to the formula? What do we do if there is a major drought?

·       Pruning schedule – pruning after 2-5 years? for structural health, then every 5 years for broken diseased, branch removal?

·       Maintenance of the inventory – Should we do more than keep track of - removals, plantings and hazards and area needs?

·       Disease assessment and mitigation – how do we keep the trees we have which are threatened by another new invasive insect or disease?

2.   CBD

·       Issue is who is responsible for maintenance once the trees are planted – Village Dept., landlords, STC, Project Pride, contractors

·       We know that without extra water and tree well maintenance few of the trees we plant will continue to do well.  The tree wells are too small to support a sufficient root space

·       There are about 210 tree wells now but there could be more in the future. 

·       The Honey Locust and Ginko trees seem to be doing best now and have had no extra care or water. Species to be planted depend on series of factors including tree well size, width of sidewalk, proximity to buildings and need to have multiple species for disease insurance.

 

Council Resolution 2022-2023

Council Approved about $640,000 (need exact amounts)

·       (A)300,000 regular planting and large tree removal

·       (B)219,000 EAB removal and replacement

·       (C)121,500 for CBD wells, planting, and water trailer

How much flexibility is there in the resolution – don’t want to have to repurpose funds

We would want resolution to say something like “planning, maintaining, and increasing Ridgewood’s Shade Tree Canopy” that way we could finish off the tree inventory and do other things that might come up.

 

Questions for 2022

1.   Shade Tree planting - Clarify the budget

o   (A) Includes Crane and contracting for big trees ($80,000)

o   Leaves $220,000 for planting, and watering @ (500 planting and 200 watering) 314 trees

o   (B) Will planting be combined with ASH replacement if so, assume 120 removals (1,000 each = 120,0000)

o   Leaves 100,000 for replacement

o   Total # trees could be 400 -425

o   Questions:

§  How will bid be structured – by tree species, by plant and water together or separate how many waterings (depends on planting time)

§  Bid will include water bags, supports, mulch and deer protection (where), some form of DEEP ROOT in certain areas.

§  What species will be bid

§  Where will they be planted – preference to EAB removal areas, resident requests, areas in need, other factors like parks or Village property

§  Bid request should go out July 1, 2022

§  Should there be 2 plantings, bid separately so they can be supervised? Does the # trees impact quality of work or tree availability?

§  When do we know how many Ash trees will come down?

§  Other factors to consider

 

2.   CBD Well/Re-planting

o   Assume 1,500 per well

o   Trailer cost 11,500 -15,000

o   Estimate 70 -75 trees/wells

o   Includes tree removal, soil enhancement

o   What are the objectives for the CBD trees?  Shade Canopy, decoration, variety or uniformity.

§  Decisions depend on location - width of sidewalk building heights etc.) focus is on species that will survive – “native” not a requirement

o   Expansion of tree well where possible (likely no more than 1 row of bricks) who does this work?

o   Selection of best water/air tube system – need to be able to fill quickly, also long term after water bags are gone capacity of the tube reservoir

o   What are the locations

§  Eastside / westside

§  Want to group plantings for traffic, police management

§  Ridgewood Ave – Broad – 3-4 on other streets?

§  Who gets to make the decision (is there need to share plan with Council, CBD groups - Chamber etc.?)

o   When will planting happen – how will it impact the other Shade Tree planting? Can we do both at the same time.

o   Do we have commitment to support watering for 2 years then in droughts?

o   Need a plan well by well with what each well will get.

o   May be too much for one year – hold over some for 2023-2024?

o   Other factors to consider